Have you ever started reading a book with no expectations at all? That’s how I started reading “All the Light We Cannot See” by Anthony Doerr, a book I received as Christmas present. Little did I know that this book would irreversibly win my heart with its touching stories and beautiful language, all wrapped up in a mysterious aura.
In a nutshell
“All the Light We Cannot See” is a historical fiction book, focusing on the World War II period. It tells the story of two children, a girl and a boy, each belonging to opposing fronts of the war: France and Germany.
From France we are presented with Marie-Laure, a curious and brave girl with “an air of otherworldliness“, who unfortunately became fully blind at the age of 6. On the other side, we find Werner, an orphan German boy passionate about radios and engineering.
Their stories unfold at the same time, over a period of approx. 10 years (1934-1944). Both their lives change dramatically as the war intensifies: while Marie-Laure moves from Paris to Saint-Malo (a walled port city in northwestern France) to take refuge, Werner is accepted to a Nazi military school because of his gift for radio mechanics.
All the Light We Cannot See – what does it mean?
Because I was a bit puzzled about the title, I did a short research regarding its interpretation. According to the author, the title has a three-fold meaning.
First of all, it is a reference to “the wavelengths of the electromagnetic spectrum that are beyond the ability of human eyes to detect (radio waves, of course, being the most relevant)” (Doerr, 2013).
Secondly, the title is a metaphor suggesting “the countless invisible stories buried within World War II” (Doerr, 2013), for example, the stories of ordinary children.
Thirdly, it is also an allusion to the situations when too much time is spent focusing only on “a small slice of the spectrum of possibilities” (Doerr, 2013). Light is like a mantra for the whole story, being mentioned many times throughout the book:
“So how, children, does the brain, which lives without a spark of light, build for us a world full of light?”
It was interesting to find out, after reading the book, that Anthony Doerr had three main sources of inspiration when building the main narratives of the book:
- the magic of radio transmissions: “I also wanted to conjure a time when it was a miracle to hear the voice of a distant stranger in our homes, in our ears” (Scribner Magazine, 2014)
- a visit to the city of Saint-Malo, destroyed almost completely during World War II (Doerr, 2014)
- how French cultural and natural science treasures were sent away in order to be protected when Germans invaded Paris (Doerr, 2014)
From a reader’s point of view, I would like to share with you three main insights I’ve identified while reading this book: (1) the transcendence of human nature, (2) the side issues that arise when living during wartime, and (3) the colorful language and expressions used by the author.
Dual perspective on war
As the author chose to depict the stories of a German boy and a French girl, we are presented with a dual perspective on war – the ones attacking and the ones being attacked. Doerr illustrates how both sides of the war have a human component, and how human nature transcends over tumultuous times and creates bridges starting from common interests such as art or science.
I’ve personally started to develop as much sympathy for Werner as I did for Marie-Laure, even though Werner was officially part of the villains’ side.
Life during wartime
The author touches upon many themes related to life during wartime in the subplots of the book, for example: local women organizing themselves in a French Resistance movement, post-traumatic stress disorder of military veterans, and the refugees’ experiences as they move to a different city (or country) to escape from war. All these do not only shine light upon World War II, but also on the current conflicts taking place around the world.
“All the Light We Cannot See” was the first book I’ve ever read that has a blind person as the main character, and I think the author did a very good job in depicting the implications of this impairment. For example, it is known that blind people compensate for their lack of sight by having their other senses enhanced, and Doerr translated into words the synesthetic experiences of Marie-Laure:
“The eggs taste like clouds” (when eating omelet)
“She’s eating wedges of wet sunlight” (when eating peaches)
As you can imagine, I fully recommend reading this novel! It will not only give you a different look on the times during World War II, but it will also keep you fully engaged with its short chapters, back and forth movements in time, thought-provoking reflections about life, and characters that will slowly but surely slip into your heart.
If you would like to buy this book, please consider using these links: Amazon link | Waterstones link. Thank you!
Have you read any historical fiction novel? Which one(s) do you recommend?
‘Till next time … happy reading!
PS: If you want to learn more about Doerr, I think this interview is a good starting point. I really like the way we writes and talks, and I plan to read his other books as well (About Grace, The Shell Collector, Memory Wall, and Four Seasons in Rome).
Images from Simon & Schuster | allisonanimates.tumblr.com | theodysseyonline.com | pinterest.com | mnhn.fr | catholicworldreport.com
4 thoughts on “A dual perspective on war: All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr (book review)”
I’ve had this book on my shelf for a fairly long time but something puts me off picking it up- I think I’m worried it will be overly sentimental for me somehow! Yet I know the book has become phenomenally popular and your review suggests that it’s nothing like I fear it will be. The info about Doerr’s intentions in the book and in the title make it sound much more my kind of book than I’d feared if would be. Time to pick it up I think!
You should give it a try! From my point of view it’s not as emotional as it might seem. Given the theme and the main characters (children during WW2), there are some touching moments, but not to the point when you actually start shedding tears. I am curious to hear your thoughts after reading it 🙂
Fantastic review! This book has known so much buzz since its release, I’m surprised you managed to stay clear of it all and started it without ANY expectations! The main character being blind is what intrigues me the most about this book too. Your review makes me want to read it even more too!
Fortunately all that buzz did not get to me, and I’ve first heard about it when I received it as present. Most of the times when I read very praised books I end up being disappointed … The less I know, the better the experience is 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person